Skip to content
ASTRO
Continue with email

Back to Field Guides · Part of the Owner Protection Stack →

Owner Field Guide · Aug 17, 2026 · 13 min read

Short-Term Rental Insurance Providers: What Owners Should Compare Before Choosing Coverage

Policies, damage waivers, and platform protections are three different things sold as one word. Comparing them starts with knowing which is which.

We write these for owners. No one pays to appear in them, no one pays to rank, and we earn nothing when you choose a provider.

Three categories of short-term rental protection compared: a regulated insurance policy, a damage waiver, and a platform protection.

Owner Protection Stack

ASTRO does not sell insurance, endorse any provider named here, or receive compensation for provider examples. This article is educational only—not insurance, legal, tax, or financial advice. Provider names, categories, and coverage details are research starting points that change frequently; confirm everything against each provider’s current materials and your own written policy. ASTRO records what protects your property; it never decides it. No policy, product, or provider is required for membership, verification, the registry, or the Owners Exchange.

There are dozens of companies that will sell a short-term rental owner “protection.” They are not the same kind of thing. Some are regulated insurance policies. Some are damage-protection products that are not insurance at all. Some are booking-platform benefits that exist only while a guest is booked through that one platform. Choosing well starts with knowing which is which.

A cap quoted in an article is stale the day the product page changes. A cap confirmed in writing at purchase is coverage.

This guide is the comparison companion to the five-layer insurance protection stack. That guide describes the layers every owner should understand. This one helps you choose between the companies that sell them. When you have made comparisons, write them into the coverage worksheet so next year’s you can see what this year’s you confirmed.

The three-way distinction, and who you buy it from

There are three kinds of protection: a Policy, a Waiver, and a Platform benefit. A Broker is not a fourth kind — it is one way to buy the first. Four questions sort any company, and nearly every confusion in this market comes from comparing across these categories as if they were interchangeable.

Badge legend used below: Policy · Broker (places you with a carrier) · Waiver (protection product, not insurance) · Platform (channel-specific). A company can wear more than one badge; when it does, that is the first thing to untangle.

Policies & brokers — regulated coverage, and who places it

A Policy is written by a regulated carrier that stands behind the claim. A Broker does not insure you itself—it shops carriers and places you on one of their policies. Both belong here because both put you on regulated insurance; the difference is who you are actually buying from. Providers are listed alphabetically within each category.

Policies also differ in whether the carrier is admitted (licensed by your state insurance department, with its rates and forms filed there, and backed by the state guaranty fund if the carrier fails) or non-admitted, also called surplus lines (allowed to cover risks admitted carriers decline, with more flexible forms but no guaranty-fund backstop). Many short-term-rental policies are surplus lines. That is common and legitimate, but ask which one you are buying, and read the NAIC consumer resources or your state insurance department's page before you choose.

CBIZ Vacation Rental Insurance Policy

CBIZ launched its National Vacation Rental Insurance Program in June 2025, backed by an A-rated carrier under delegated underwriting, with liability limits of $1M per occurrence and $2M aggregate, per its announcement. It is sold through independent agents and brokers, not direct to owners. CBIZ does not name the carrier on its public pages, so ask.

Ask:

  • Who is the A-rated carrier, and is the policy admitted or non-admitted in my state?
  • Are STRs, long-term rentals, second homes, and vacant periods each treated differently?
  • Are guest injury, owner contents, amenities, and loss of income all included?
  • Which agent or broker in my state can quote it?

Owner translation: Compare CBIZ against Proper and Steadily when you want a dedicated vacation-rental program; the deciding detail is the current policy form and carrier, not the brand's history.

InsuraGuest Policy

InsuraGuest sells a no-fault, in-stay guest liability product as a property-level subscription ($69 or $99 a month per property on its pricing page, pausable), including no-fault medical payments up to $25,000. It can also be charged per night through PMS integrations such as Guesty, Hostaway and Hostfully. It is narrower than a full property or business-income policy and is meant to sit in front of core coverage, not replace it.

Ask:

  • Exactly which in-stay incidents are covered, and is it primary to my own policy?
  • Does coverage depend on a PMS integration being active?
  • What does it leave to my core property and liability policy?

Owner translation: Compare InsuraGuest against a damage waiver when you want a first-dollar, no-fault layer for in-stay incidents, and pair it with a core property policy, because it is not one.

Obie Broker

Obie is a licensed insurance agency that places landlords and investors with third-party carriers. Its current site describes cover for single-family, multifamily, apartment and condo rentals and does not describe a short-term-rental product, so treat it as a landlord-policy route and confirm in writing that the placed policy permits nightly stays.

Ask:

  • Will the placed policy explicitly permit short-term rental use, direct bookings, and vacancy?
  • Who is the actual insurer, and is Obie acting as agent or broker here?
  • What endorsements are required, and what STR-relevant exclusions apply?

Owner translation: Compare Obie against going direct to a dedicated STR policy when you want one agency to shop several carriers. The coverage still lives in whichever carrier's form you land on, and a landlord form that excludes nightly stays is not STR coverage.

Proper Insurance Policy

Proper sells a commercial short-term-rental policy meant to replace a homeowner or landlord policy: building, contents, business revenue protection, and commercial general liability from $1M, available in all 50 states and DC per its materials. Proper is part of Specialty Program Group, a HUB International company, and its policies are written through Lloyd's and Concert Specialty, which typically means non-admitted (surplus lines) cover.

Ask:

  • Does this fully replace my homeowner or landlord policy, or sit alongside it?
  • What building, contents, liability, and loss-of-income limits apply, and what is excluded?
  • Is the policy admitted or non-admitted in my state?
  • Are direct bookings and vacant periods covered the same as OTA bookings?

Owner translation: Compare Proper against CBIZ and Steadily when you want a single dedicated STR policy rather than patching a homeowner policy with endorsements. A related point: a damage waiver such as Waivo sits in a different category from a policy like this one, even when both are sold to the same owner.

Safely Policy

Safely pairs a primary insurance policy with a guest-screening layer. Per its materials the policy reaches up to $1M structural and $1M liability, with $25K contents, sold through On Demand Insurance Agency. Read it as a policy with a prevention layer attached, not two separate purchases.

Ask:

  • Am I buying screening only, the protection policy only, or the bundle?
  • Does protection depend on every guest being screened first, and what happens if one fails?
  • Does it apply to direct bookings, and what guest data is collected?

Owner translation: Compare Safely against Truvi when you want prevention and a backstop from one vendor; the deciding question is whether the insurance half is broad enough to lean on.

Steadily Policy

Steadily writes landlord and short-term-rental cover, including Airbnb- and Vrbo-style rentals, through its own carrier, Steadily Insurance Company, with Steadily Insurance Agency as the selling agency. Its 50-state claim is made for its rental products generally; confirm STR availability and nightly-use terms for your state on the quote.

Ask:

  • Is this a true STR policy, a landlord policy, or a landlord policy with STR permissions?
  • Are direct bookings, furnishings, and loss of business income covered?
  • What happens to coverage during vacant periods between stays?

Owner translation: Compare Steadily against CBIZ and Proper when you want a modern quote flow, and confirm that "rental property" on the quote means "short-term rental business."

Damage-protection products — not insurance

RentalGuardian (Home Guardian / Home Guardian+) Waiver

RentalGuardian is a damage- and liability-protection administrator; Home Guardian and Home Guardian+ are its plan tiers. RentalGuardian Holdings is a division of Inhabit IQ, which also owns the InsureStays licensed agency. Tier limits are not published; they are quoted by sales, so get them in writing.

Ask:

  • Which tier is offered, and who administers and underwrites it?
  • Is this damage protection, liability protection, trip protection, or a bundle?
  • What are the limits and exclusions, in writing?
  • Does it require the guest to buy or accept anything, and does it apply to direct bookings?

Owner translation: Compare RentalGuardian's tiers against Truvi and Waivo when protection will sit inside your booking or PMS flow; the deciding detail is the tier's written limits and who administers claims.

Truvi (formerly Superhog) Waiver

Truvi combines guest screening, ID verification, and a damage-protection guarantee. Per its materials the guarantee is configurable from $0 up to $1M per booking, in tiers, and requires the guest to be screened. It is a risk-management product, not an insurance policy, and is built with direct bookings in mind.

Ask:

  • Which tier am I on, and what is the per-booking limit and any owner-paid first amount?
  • Does protection apply only after a guest is screened?
  • Which booking channels and PMS integrations are supported?
  • What documentation is required for a claim, and who pays it?

Owner translation: Compare Truvi against Safely and Waivo when you want screening plus guest-damage protection for direct bookings, and insist the vendor say which half you are relying on for a given incident.

Waivo Waiver

Waivo is a damage-protection product that replaces a security deposit: it reimburses guest-caused damage with no deductible, with theft claims requiring a police report. Plan limits are published in the range of $500 to $20,000 per booking in third-party summaries; confirm the current limit on Waivo's own terms. It is not liability insurance.

Ask:

  • What is the per-stay limit, and does it cover contents and building damage or only guest-caused loss?
  • Does it apply to direct bookings and OTA bookings alike?
  • What proof and what deadline are required to be reimbursed?

Owner translation: Compare Waivo against a security deposit and against Truvi when you want first-dollar guest-damage recovery without holding deposits. It does not replace property insurance.

Platform protections — channel-specific, not a substitute

Airbnb AirCover for Hosts Platform

AirCover for Hosts bundles host damage protection (up to $3M) and host liability insurance (up to $1M), governed by Airbnb's terms and applying only to stays booked through Airbnb. It is not a substitute for your own policy: it does nothing for direct bookings, off-platform repeat guests, or vacant nights.

Ask:

  • Does it apply to this specific reservation, and what are the deadlines and exclusions?
  • Is this damage protection, liability insurance, or both, and what proof is required?
  • How does it interact with my own policy?

Owner translation: Compare AirCover against your own policy, not against another provider.

Vrbo Host Protections Platform

Vrbo provides a liability-insurance component for eligible reservations, reported at $1M per property per year, plus accidental-damage-protection options a guest may buy. Sources disagree on whether the liability layer is primary or excess to the host's own policy, and it does not cover damage to your own property. Confirm both points in Vrbo's current terms.

Ask:

  • Does the liability protection apply to this reservation, and is it primary or excess?
  • Did the guest purchase accidental-damage protection, and what limit and deadline apply?
  • Does a deductible apply if my own insurer does not contribute?

Owner translation: Compare Vrbo's program against your own policy the same way: it is channel-specific, so a direct booking or an off-Vrbo stay carries none of it.

Side by side (October 2026)

Headline figures as published by each provider or reported in October 2026. They change; confirm the number on the provider's current page and in your written policy before relying on it.

ProviderCategoryWho carries the riskHeadline limitsPricing modelHow you buy
CBIZ Vacation Rental InsurancePolicyA-rated carrier (unnamed)$1M / $2M liabilityAnnual premiumThrough an agent or broker
InsuraGuestPolicyInsurer (in-stay liability only)No-fault medical to $25K$69 or $99 / month, or per night via PMSDirect or PMS integration
ObieBrokerWhichever carrier places youDepends on placed policyAnnual premiumDirect (agency)
Proper InsurancePolicyLloyd's / Concert SpecialtyCGL from $1MAnnual premiumDirect
SafelyPolicyInsurer via On Demand Insurance Agency$1M structural, $1M liability, $25K contentsPer stay / planDirect or PMS integration
SteadilyPolicySteadily Insurance CompanyBy quoteAnnual premiumDirect
RentalGuardianWaiverAdministrator (Inhabit IQ)By quotePer bookingThrough booking or PMS flow
TruviWaiverTruvi guarantee$0 to $1M per booking, tieredPer bookingDirect or PMS integration
WaivoWaiverWaivo guaranteePlans reported $500 to $20KPer bookingDirect or PMS integration
Airbnb AirCoverPlatformAirbnb program$3M damage, $1M liabilityIncluded on Airbnb bookingsAutomatic on Airbnb
Vrbo protectionsPlatformVrbo program$1M liability (reported)Included / guest-purchasedAutomatic on Vrbo

How to compare, once you know the category

Within the right category, compare on the axes that actually decide a claim—not on headline marketing:

  • Underlying insurance vs waiver. Is a regulated carrier on the hook, or is this a contractual guarantee that can decline outside its narrow terms?
  • What is covered. Property peril, liability, business income/loss-of-rents, contents, amenities, and guest-caused damage are five different things—confirm each, not “covered” in the abstract.
  • Exclusions and conditions. Business use, undisclosed amenities, vacancy, pets, parties, and intentional acts are where coverage quietly ends.
  • Direct-booking applicability. Does the protection follow the property, or only certain channels?
  • Channel dependence. Platform benefits lapse off-platform and while vacant—map every way a guest can book.
  • Claims handling. Who files, by when, with what proof, and who actually pays?
  • Written-confirmation questions. Anything a salesperson says that is not on the policy form is not coverage.
  • Material-change triggers. See the next section—these silently break last year’s comparison.
  • State and product availability. Programs, tiers, and caps vary by state and change without notice.

Material-change triggers

Any one of these can silently void the comparison you did last year—because it changes the risk your existing coverage was priced for:

  • Adding an amenity (pool, hot tub, dock, golf cart, fire pit).
  • Allowing pets.
  • Launching direct bookings or a new channel.
  • Increasing occupancy or adding events.
  • Renovating or changing the property’s use.
  • Transferring the property to an LLC or trust.
  • Adding or changing a property manager.

The fillable twin of this list lives in the coverage worksheet’s change-trigger sheet. When one of these happens, re-confirm coverage in writing—do not assume the old answer still holds. Provider ownership and product tiers change; the questions do not.

Why this matters for ASTRO owners

ASTRO is built for short-term rental owners, and it keeps a property’s record separate from the shifting products layered on top of it. Insurance, waivers, and platform terms all change on their own schedules; the property, and the durable record of it, do not. ASTRO records what protects your property; it never decides it. No policy, product, or provider is required for membership, verification, the registry, or the Owners Exchange. A registry identity is not an insurance policy, listing-control verification is not liability coverage, and Owners Exchange settlement does not insure the building. What ASTRO gives you is a stable place to stand while you compare the coverage that is genuinely yours to choose.

Three claims, three different payers

Category is easiest to see in a claim. Each of these lands on a different layer.

  • A guest slips on the pool deck during a direct booking. No platform protection applies, because the stay was not booked on a platform. A waiver will not respond, because waivers cover damage to your property, not injuries. The claim lands on your Policy's general liability, or on an in-stay liability layer such as InsuraGuest if you carry one.
  • A guest breaks a television and stains a sofa on an Airbnb stay. AirCover's damage protection may respond on that reservation. If you also carry a waiver on the booking, check its terms for which one pays first. Your Policy is the backstop for anything both decline.
  • A kitchen fire starts on a vacant night between stays. No guest, no booking: platforms and waivers are out. Only your Policy responds, and only if it covers vacancy and business use. This is the scenario that exposes a homeowner policy with no STR endorsement.

The Simplest Counterargument

Most owners will never file a catastrophic claim, and comparing a dozen providers across nine axes is real work for a risk that may never arrive. Buying the cheapest adequate policy and moving on is a defensible choice, and this guide’s framework can feel like overkill for a single, simple property.

That objection is fair. What still holds is that the cost of comparing is paid once, in an afternoon, while the cost of discovering a category mistake is paid at the worst possible moment—after a loss, when the “protection” you counted on turns out to have been a platform benefit that lapsed, or a waiver that never covered the peril. You do not need every layer. You do need to know which category each thing you are paying for belongs to.

What breaks when owners get this wrong

  • A platform benefit (AirCover, Vrbo) is treated as the property’s insurance—and a direct booking or vacant night is uninsured.
  • A damage waiver is mistaken for a policy—and a fire, a liability claim, or lost income falls into a gap it never covered.
  • A homeowner or landlord policy is assumed to permit nightly rentals without written confirmation—and business use is excluded at claim time.
  • A cap read in an old article no longer matches the current product page—and the owner is under-covered by a number that changed.
  • An amenity, pet, or entity change is never disclosed—and a material-change trigger quietly voids the coverage.
  • The company that pays the claim turns out to be a different entity than the website that sold it—because “who backs it” was never asked.

The worst time to learn which category your protection belonged to is after the claim.

Educational information only—not insurance, legal, tax, or financial advice. Provider categories, coverage, limits, ownership, and availability change; confirm current terms directly with each provider and read your own policy form before relying on any coverage.